Watch This to Make Sense of the World

Summary

The speaker discussed the historical dominance of elites over politics and society, how the middle class was co-opted to control the masses, and the subsequent rise of mass movements challenging elite power. They highlighted the role of technology, such as the printing press and social media, in redistributing power to the masses, leading to populist movements and democratic participation, albeit within a system still largely controlled by elites. The pandemic further exposed systemic inequalities and elite control, prompting a call for individuals to resist manipulation and opt out of the societal rat race to reclaim personal agency. Watch This to Make Sense of the World

Tags

Tip: click a paragraph to jump to the exact moment in the video. Watch This to Make Sense of the World

  1. 00:05 these are chaotic times these are confusing times perplexing
  2. 00:13 we are all baffled we are all puzzled
  3. 00:19 we all worried a trifle paranoid perhaps weary cautious
  4. 00:28 we’ve been self-isolating long before social distancing and we have been wearing masks of the virtual kind long before the pandemic
  5. 00:42 we all reach out and then we retreat approach avoidance and this is because
  6. 00:50 the world had become an enigma wrapped in a puzzle
  7. 00:56 embedded in a mystery in short we no longer feel at home
  8. 01:06 i will try to be of some help here i’ll try to introduce order structure and meaning into the world as it is today and i will
  9. 01:18 attempt to do this by studying the way the world had always been
  10. 01:26 the immutable unchangeable patterns and rules that govern our universe now
  11. 01:33 and always had for millennia we are human beings we have been human
  12. 01:41 beings 5 000 years ago we have societies and cultures we have
  13. 01:47 had societies and cultures 10 000 years ago there’s nothing new under the sun and
  14. 01:55 our internal dynamics may be affected by fads and fashions and technologies
  15. 02:01 but they haven’t changed that much it takes millions of years for such changes to occur and we are
  16. 02:09 a very young species so i think we can learn a lot by
  17. 02:16 studying history let’s start with the fact that politics
  18. 02:23 has been with us forever there had been politicians in ancient babylon
  19. 02:30 there had been politicians in persia arguing with king cirques there have been politicians
  20. 02:39 who surrounded alexander the great who had debated who had
  21. 02:46 implemented policies but for millennia until very recently politicians had represented the interests
  22. 02:59 of the elites politicians were the long arms the extensions
  23. 03:07 they were the employees they carried out the instructions of the elites
  24. 03:14 they managed politicians managed the bureaucracies
  25. 03:20 what some conspiracy theorists call the deep states the deep state politicians managed
  26. 03:28 the bureaucracies the agencies the institutions of governance which
  27. 03:34 were required to ensure the smooth running of polities and economies
  28. 03:44 and who needed political entities and economies to run smoothly yes
  29. 03:52 you guessed it the elites it was all about the elites
  30. 03:58 politicians were pawns in a game of chess played by the elites that has been the
  31. 04:06 case for well over 10 000 documented years
  32. 04:12 in prehistory and in written history politicians were therefore totally
  33. 04:19 identified and at the mercy of ruling elites now the identity of the elites sometimes may have changed
  34. 04:32 sometimes the clergy were members of the elites sometimes not sometimes the aristocracy sometimes not sometimes only the royal family
  35. 04:45 and there were periods in history where intellectuals were actually among the elites like today so the composition of the
  36. 04:52 elites who exactly is an insider who is a member of the club that depends
  37. 04:59 on the period in history but throughout history there was a tiny
  38. 05:05 tiny tiny crust much less than one percent and this tiny sliver of humanity used bureaucracy
  39. 05:16 used institutions used the law and used politicians not necessarily to
  40. 05:25 accomplish any goals but to secure an environment in which
  41. 05:31 goals can be accomplished a favorable environment a stable
  42. 05:37 environment sometimes nepotistic sometimes chronist environment networks of patronage it’s true but the emphasis was on stability and a playing field which favors the elites
  43. 05:54 at all times and allows them to increase their wealth
  44. 06:00 in a linear manner over uninterrupted centuries
  45. 06:06 wealth amalgamation wealth creation and the distribution of wealth and the
  46. 06:12 transfer of wealth between generations were the main focus of elites
  47. 06:18 throughout history and to this very day but something happened something
  48. 06:25 happened at the end of the 18th century
  49. 06:32 starting with the french revolution the organizing principles of political establishments were challenged monarchies fell apart
  50. 06:45 empires disintegrated something was afoot and what had
  51. 06:51 happened what precipitated this sudden change was the printing press the printing
  52. 06:59 press democratized knowledge and access to knowledge suddenly much
  53. 07:07 larger swathes of humanity had access to data
  54. 07:13 which previously had been the exclusive reserve and domain for example
  55. 07:19 of the church the vernacular bible martin luther king’s bible king james’s
  56. 07:25 bible they undermined the authority of the church and the church of course was in most
  57. 07:32 eras of history a member of the elite privileged member of the elite
  58. 07:38 so this was the first development the second development
  59. 07:44 which precipitated the transition from elites to masses the second development was the sheer
  60. 07:50 numbers population on earth had begun to explode numerically there were many more people who belong to the masses than people who
  61. 08:02 belong to the elites it became much more difficult to control these
  62. 08:08 giant clusters of population the black death which had decimated one one
  63. 08:15 third to one half of europe’s population only made matters worse as far as the
  64. 08:22 elites because we’re concerned because it made labor very scarce
  65. 08:29 and it it necessitated a vast transfer of wealth
  66. 08:35 from the elites back to the masses back to the people in other words labor wages increased
  67. 08:43 dramatically because there were no workers left most of them had died in the black death in the plague
  68. 08:51 so the increase in numbers the increase in literacy the
  69. 08:57 democratization of science and scientific endeavor and inventions gave rise to the
  70. 09:03 copyright and patent laws gradually power
  71. 09:09 was seeping away filtering out from the hands of the elites
  72. 09:15 down to the masses and a new layer was created between the elites and the masses the middle class the middle class aspired to join the elites but belonged
  73. 09:27 psychologically culturally historically and societally belong to the masses
  74. 09:34 the middle class was a bridge between the masses and the elites and the elite elites
  75. 09:41 saw an opportunity here to co-opt the middle classes so they introduced dreams and fantasies
  76. 09:49 the american dream the american dream was about members of the middle class becoming
  77. 09:56 members of the elite the elite in other words became socially mobile now you could be born on the wrong side of the tracks
  78. 10:07 and end up in a mansion or president of the united states so degrees of social mobility and social
  79. 10:14 freedom were introduced into the system by the elites as a way to compromise the middle class
  80. 10:22 and control the masses via the middle class because you see the masses hated the
  81. 10:28 elites always always the masses wanted to kill the elites and very often did
  82. 10:35 the muscles once masses wanted to destroy the elites because the masses were perniciously and virulently and
  83. 10:42 viscerally envious of the elites they wanted to remove the object that created these frustrations in envy they wanted to literally assassinate the elites and in the french revolution and in the russian revolution they did
  84. 10:59 copiously but the masses did not hate the middle class the masses saw a reasonable chance an opportunity to join the middle class
  85. 11:10 in a variety of ways by for example via education via learning a trade or a skill
  86. 11:18 apprenticeship so the middle class was an outlet it was a steam valve because it
  87. 11:25 it enabled the illusion because it was an illusion it was a lie it enabled the illusion of social mobility and it allowed the elites to use
  88. 11:39 one part of the muscles against another divide and conquer the middle class
  89. 11:45 became the trojan horse of the masses became the fifth column
  90. 11:51 the middle class betrayed the masses they were traitors as the fathers of
  91. 11:58 communism had correctly observed the middle class chose signs
  92. 12:04 and it chose the elites and it went against the masses
  93. 12:10 so there was a three-pronged war going on the elites and their cohorts the middle
  94. 12:16 classes against the working classes the masses
  95. 12:23 so for millennia politicians also had to choose sites and until very
  96. 12:31 recently they had chosen the sides of the elites then as the middle class had expanded
  97. 12:37 they chose the side of a middle class but there was not much difference between siding with the elites and siding with
  98. 12:43 the middle class the middle class was the where the emissaries were the extensions of the elite
  99. 12:50 they were like the poor cousin cousins of the elite they belong to the elite family they
  100. 12:57 were on their way to becoming elites some of them did so politicians didn’t have a hard time choosing between elites and middle class they were one and the same but they were definitely against the
  101. 13:08 masses the founding fathers of the united states of america ostensibly allegedly the greatest
  102. 13:15 democracy on earth detested the mosses they were terrified of democracy
  103. 13:21 that’s why they created the electoral college they firmly believed that mass democracy
  104. 13:28 leads to tyranny and history bore them out hitler was an elected leader
  105. 13:36 on a much lesser note so our bolsonaro so is so was donald trump
  106. 13:44 the masses the masses gravitate towards strong men
  107. 13:52 they end up via the process of mass democracy creating tyranny and so
  108. 14:00 the founding fathers were terrified of the masses and they created a non-representative democracy
  109. 14:08 and as the as the politicians were trying to constrain the masses by
  110. 14:15 collaborating with the middle classes and the elites the masses were becoming more and more
  111. 14:22 restless because they were becoming more and more numerous the masses had to compete for scarce
  112. 14:29 economic resources and these scarce economic resources were hogged
  113. 14:35 where monopolized were devoured by the middle classes and the elite
  114. 14:41 income inequality reflects the fact that the vast majority of wealth assets
  115. 14:49 and income is owned by something like one percent of the
  116. 14:55 population and that something like 70 to 80 of population go to bed hungry
  117. 15:02 or destitute or desolate have no meaning and purpose in life
  118. 15:08 and are subjected to mass fantasies mass manufactured fantasies
  119. 15:14 and so as the 18th century bled into the 19th century industrial
  120. 15:20 revolution the industrial revolution leveraged the masses to create consumer goods
  121. 15:28 and other modes of transport and communication and so on construction for the middle
  122. 15:35 classes so the work of the of the working classes the proletariat in marx
  123. 15:41 in marx in marxian terms marx systems the work of the the labor of the working
  124. 15:47 classes had been converted into consumer goods of the middle classes
  125. 15:54 and permanent capital assets of the elites and the working classes resented this
  126. 16:01 hence socialism hence communism hence nazism hence fascism
  127. 16:09 these were all movements of the masses movements of the working classes in
  128. 16:16 short for 10 000 years or let’s say for 9800 years the elites were in control they created bureaucracies and they let
  129. 16:27 politicians run the bureaucracies in the last 300 years a middle class
  130. 16:35 had been created it emerged from the masses and it reverted to the elites it collaborated with the elites
  131. 16:42 it compromised itself by collaborating with the elites and the elites were fine with this
  132. 16:48 because the middle class had always been small and they you know the elites threw them
  133. 16:54 some crumbs to make them feel good and encouraged fantasies of social mobility and riches and you know the american dream and the middle middle class was happy and the elites were happy and then in the last 100 years
  134. 17:07 the masses could take it no more and we started to see mass movements
  135. 17:14 mass movements which had all the hallmarks of religions secular religions and which were founded
  136. 17:21 on ideology ideology is the poor man the ignorant man’s
  137. 17:28 philosophy it’s basic it’s demagogic it’s not very sophisticated
  138. 17:37 you don’t have to have to have too much brain to comprehend it it has it’s prescriptive it tells you
  139. 17:43 what to do and it’s dichotomous it’s black and white thinking there’s the enemy and
  140. 17:50 there’s you there’s us and them so ideologies are a poor ignorant men’s philosophy
  141. 17:59 and of course ideologies had quickly transformed into religions secular religions with secular saints secular rituals just have a look at any may day parade
  142. 18:11 in soviet russia or in china to understand what i’m saying in north korea today so the masses
  143. 18:18 reacted to their enslavement by the elites and later on by the traitors the middle class they reacted
  144. 18:31 with mass movements with mass ideologies and they tried
  145. 18:38 to uproot to dislodge
  146. 18:44 the elites at first so the first impulse was kill the elites
  147. 18:50 and they did physically they killed the elites they decapitated them they shot them
  148. 18:58 but then the mass movements change course mysteriously
  149. 19:07 sometimes they change course because they became the establishment the communists became bolsheviks and
  150. 19:14 bolsheviks ruled russia so there was no need they became the elite the new elite the nomenclature so in some cases mass movements were
  151. 19:25 compromised by their own success the nazis which were an outlier
  152. 19:33 outside outcast political movement had become the rules of germany
  153. 19:39 same with the communists in russia and so same with the fascists in italy the fascists were or the leaders of of the fascist movement including mussolini were actually communists
  154. 19:50 gerbils was a communist all mass movements have very close affinity and so
  155. 19:58 when they came to power they became the establishment and they did not want the masses to
  156. 20:04 continue to be rebellious they did not want the masses to identify
  157. 20:10 them as the new elites and then to attack them as they had attacked the old elites so a new
  158. 20:17 consensus had emerged the masses now didn’t try to kill the elite
  159. 20:23 they didn’t try to beat the elite they tried to join the elite they demanded a part of the spoils they
  160. 20:30 demanded a re-division and redistribution of wealth and we and we came up with the income
  161. 20:36 tax the income tax is the elite’s way of redistributing some of the wealth some of the money back to the poor
  162. 20:48 it was a concession by the elite on the surface because if you look at
  163. 20:54 the numbers most of the money most most of the tax money including the latest
  164. 21:00 the latest relief packages covered 19 relief packages most of the money goes actually to the
  165. 21:07 middle class or to rich people and to companies enterprises corporations not to poor
  166. 21:13 people so it was a soap it was a confabulation it was a lie but comfortable lie
  167. 21:20 so distributive taxation socially progressive taxation was the
  168. 21:28 way that the elites allowed the masses to share in some of the benefits the welfare state was born as a way to contain the masses and convince them
  169. 21:39 that the elites are going out of their way to make life happier and richer
  170. 21:47 in every possible way suddenly there were mass institutions of culture and art available museums opened their gates
  171. 21:56 to the masses which never happened before so
  172. 22:04 this is where we were [Music] this is where we were in the 1960s
  173. 22:13 by the 1960s all monarchies and all empires had crumbled in slow motion
  174. 22:20 this slow motion was accelerated after the first world war when the inefficacy incompetence
  175. 22:27 and sheer stupidity of the elites was exposed the malevolence
  176. 22:34 the the the real conspiracies the i mean the underbelly the simi side of the elites was exposed
  177. 22:41 glaringly in the first world war and a whole generation of young men was decimated so after 1918 and well into the end of the 1960s empires fell apart
  178. 22:53 and monarchies vanish vanished the masses started to make demands and
  179. 23:01 by now the masses were no longer no longer homicidal they no longer wanted to kill the elites
  180. 23:07 they have tried this it didn’t work the masses had discovered something about themselves they are not good at
  181. 23:14 governing the masses tried communism the masses tried fascism the masses tried nazism it didn’t work
  182. 23:23 well the masses even tried labor governance labour parties in various parts of the world from italy
  183. 23:29 to the united kingdom it didn’t work well either masses are not built to govern
  184. 23:36 they don’t have the internal intellectual capital they don’t have a tradition of governing and they don’t have the necessary skills and knowledge etc etc they also are not well connected
  185. 23:47 governance is about networking is about leveraging social capital the masses didn’t have this
  186. 23:53 so by the 1960s the masters had realized that they need the elites and they need
  187. 23:59 the middle class to provide them with an environment where they as masses can survive somehow
  188. 24:07 and even potentially be socially mobile and join the middle class and so the elites and the masses
  189. 24:15 struck a truce and armistice there was a tense tense equilibrium
  190. 24:22 between elites and muscles let’s recap before we continue for a long period for
  191. 24:28 the longest period of time the elites ruled unfettered unchallenged
  192. 24:34 elites and only elites were in charge politicians were the long arms of the elites
  193. 24:40 and they managed the bureaucracies on behalf of the elites then masses began to rise for a variety
  194. 24:46 of reasons that i had mentioned and the mass the first thing the masses did they killed the elise and the masses over a period of 200 years came up with their own institutions their own their own
  195. 24:58 religions their own ideologies their own solutions and the masses tried to take over from
  196. 25:06 the elites they had narcissism they had communism and the masses discovered it’s not working they are not equipped
  197. 25:12 to govern they need the elites the intellectual needs the financial elites
  198. 25:18 the hereditary elites they need elites so what the masses did they co-opted
  199. 25:24 they they kind of negotiated a truce or an armistice or cohabitation
  200. 25:31 of co-existence with the elites and and the agents of the elites the middle class
  201. 25:38 and this is where we were in the 1960s the masses began to assert their power
  202. 25:45 and the masses formed at first in the 1930s and 40s they formed chaotic oculocrisis oculocrisis
  203. 25:53 mob rule nazi regime was an ocular crazy mob rule and they created clock races
  204. 26:01 and they executed millions of tens of millions actually of people including large parts of the elites it
  205. 26:07 didn’t work so by the 1960s everyone everything froze the elites
  206. 26:13 were where they were the middle class was in the middle middle class and the masses were awaiting everyone was in this tense tense stand up stand down like
  207. 26:25 what’s gonna happen next everyone was frozen by the lights like a deer with headlights you know the elites tried
  208. 26:35 desperately because they realized that things were going the wrong way for them they looked to the to the west and they
  209. 26:43 saw decapitated decapitated noblemen in france they looked a bit to the east and they saw a royal family bullet riddled in russia they looked
  210. 26:54 further and they saw the labour party taking over in the united kingdom the earth was shaking the elites were terrified
  211. 27:01 the elites were absolutely terrified there was a yellow scare there was a red scare so what the elites tried to do they
  212. 27:08 introduced a variety of fiction a variety of pieces of fiction a variety
  213. 27:15 of narratives a variety of stories a variety of movies movie scripts and they try to
  214. 27:21 sell the masses on these movie scripts so one of these movie scripts is liberal democracy every four years you
  215. 27:28 get to tell us who will be in the elite the elites told the masses you have power you have the power you decide who will be a member of our club which
  216. 27:39 of course is utter nonsense democracy is a sham it’s a sham it’s also an exceedingly bad idea
  217. 27:46 because democracy led to adolf hitler and not comparing but democracy led to
  218. 27:52 donald trump democracy is a horrible idea the masses are not built to govern they don’t have the
  219. 27:58 qualifications the knowledge the capacity the mentality nothing masses should not never ever vote
  220. 28:06 but the elites were so terrified so panic-stricken that they introduced universal suffrage
  221. 28:14 universal suffrage universal voting and they included minorities such as women
  222. 28:20 and ethnic minorities and so on so forth in this sweeping universal suffrage in this sweeping universal democracy and the second idea the second idea that they had introduced
  223. 28:31 was the nation state so elites tried to subdue the masses to subjugate them
  224. 28:39 to control them to manipulate them to channel their energy to derive maximum
  225. 28:45 benefit from the masses by on the one hand giving them
  226. 28:51 ill illusory freedom illusory mobility illusory
  227. 28:58 power like democracy you know democracy and if you if you study and if you work
  228. 29:04 hard you’re gonna become rich the american dream and democracy these were these were the great levelers the idea was to level the playing field egalitarianism in other words but it
  229. 29:16 became malignant under egalitarianism later on with technology we’ll talk about it so this was the idea of the elite the
  230. 29:24 elites introduced liberal democracy and the second idea that elise introduced was the nation state nation
  231. 29:31 state is a very new invention it’s less than 200 years old nationalism nationalism and democracy
  232. 29:39 these were the tools of the elites to subjugate manipulate and control the masses and
  233. 29:45 both ideas were ludicrous there were shams there were utter unmitigated nonsense there’s
  234. 29:52 no such thing as race there’s no such thing as nation and there’s no such thing as democracy
  235. 29:58 this is total psychotic hallucination
  236. 30:04 and this sham was an effort to structure the surging mobs to control them
  237. 30:12 to prevent the inevitable decapitation guillotines in the square riots in the
  238. 30:18 capital on january 6 the elites didn’t want this to happen the elites didn’t want donald
  239. 30:25 trump to happen the elites didn’t want hitler to happen except a few industrialists
  240. 30:31 and so the elite elites introduced liberal democracy and they introduced nationalism very often put together
  241. 30:39 and it backfired it backfired because to the shock of the elites
  242. 30:47 the masses wholeheartedly adopted and embraced democracy adopted
  243. 30:55 and embraced nationalism the elites became immersed
  244. 31:01 in this augmented reality that the sorry the masses became immersed
  245. 31:08 in this augmented reality the masses adopted democracy lovingly
  246. 31:16 and they regarded democracy as a way to break into the citadel of the elites the masters adopted nationalism lovingly
  247. 31:25 they saw it as a way to leverage the power of the masses and take over and redirect
  248. 31:32 the body politic the elites inventions twin inventions twin shams twin
  249. 31:38 deceptions twin illusions of democracy and nationalism backfired on them backfired on them the
  250. 31:45 great unwashed the hoi polloi the masses they leveraged democracy they leveraged democracy they used it they put in the white house
  251. 31:59 their own men donald trump for example the latest example and
  252. 32:05 the same in the philippines duterte and the same in brazil the masses discovered the power of the
  253. 32:12 vote the power of a vote was supposed to be a piece of fiction no one had it voted i mean look at voting numbers
  254. 32:19 look at voting raids throughout history no one used it no one until recently recently the masters fell
  255. 32:25 in love with the voting process and this is why still the vote or steal the election is
  256. 32:32 such a potent hashtag because the masses are really emotionally invested
  257. 32:38 emotionally invested in the vote they regard the vote as their weapon and they don’t want
  258. 32:45 anyone to take away this weapon from them to steal it as they see
  259. 32:52 at the same time technologies emerged you remember that
  260. 32:59 the printing press actually concealed
  261. 33:05 allowed the masses to congeal to cohere to become a single entity the printing press this allowed ideas to be disseminated words to be diffused the printing press
  262. 33:18 created the glue that held multitudes together and then recently we had a similar
  263. 33:25 technological revolution of similar magnitude the new technologies computing technology social media the new technologies allowed for
  264. 33:36 disintermediation the new technologies removed the layers of middle-class agents of the elites
  265. 33:44 the new technologies removed publishers so now you can publish books but by yourself the new technologies removed
  266. 33:51 editors so you have unfettered access to to news fake and real
  267. 33:57 the new technologies removed everyone that stood between you and power the new technologies empowered
  268. 34:03 the masses everyone today can be a television producer a book publisher a newspaper a
  269. 34:10 journalist etc etc everyone today with a minimal investment
  270. 34:16 can be anything and this is empowerment which is
  271. 34:22 of unprecedented proportions it took away it took away the gatekeeping functions
  272. 34:29 of the elites the elites controlled what you had read what you had learned what you were
  273. 34:35 exposed to what you saw the elites via the middle class
  274. 34:41 middle class editors middle class publishers middle class television producers middle class anchors middle class everything the elites controlled
  275. 34:52 your world your cognitions the elites controlled your found fund of
  276. 34:58 knowledge they elites decided how ignorant you’ll be and now they have lost this via these
  277. 35:06 new technologies these new technologies disempowered the elites these technologies are a transfer of power from the elites to the masses in an unbridled way
  278. 35:19 and this allowed the masses to stage populist schools there’s no other way to describe it
  279. 35:25 populist schools all over the world this allowed the elites to take over the
  280. 35:31 levels of states and establishments either to reserve to the elites so twitter revolutions for example twitter revolutions flash mobs uh
  281. 35:44 opposition figures dissidents encryption devices that allow you you know via vpns and so on
  282. 35:50 allow you to operate in hostile political environments these all this disempowerment of the
  283. 35:57 elites their technological allies and the middle class is of astounding historical implications this has never
  284. 36:09 happened before there have been rebellions of masses there’s been the spartacus rebellion
  285. 36:15 there has been the 1905 uh revolution in russia there have been many cases where the masses had risen and rebelled even the hebrew slaves
  286. 36:26 left egypt there was a rebellion of the masses rebellions of masses are documented
  287. 36:32 throughout history but they were short-lived they were sporadic they were point-like they were meaningless and they were
  288. 36:38 absolutely hopeless they were more a statement rather than a movement
  289. 36:44 the new technologies the new technologies coupled with one main one vote
  290. 36:51 gave the masses the first real chance of power the first real chance it’s self-governance and control and self-enlightenment they’ve had this
  291. 37:02 chance in the 1930s and 40s but they botched it the masses had a first shorted power through communism through fascism
  292. 37:14 through nazism and they failed they failed miserably and so for 60 years 70 years the masses had retreated because they had this traumatic
  293. 37:25 experience the masses said when we get to power we end up with adolf hitler when we get to power we end up with joseph stalin we get to power we end up with mao
  294. 37:38 so better keep away from power because when we we have power we end up killing each other better keep
  295. 37:45 away from power so for 70 years there was the masters were in a post-traumatic condition
  296. 37:51 following the mass ideologies and mass movements of the first half of the 20th century
  297. 37:57 but now they have recovered plus they had forgotten the new generations know very little about stalin and hitler
  298. 38:04 and the great depression and all these things and the new generations don’t read books
  299. 38:10 so now the masses are ready for a second attempt a second attempt at taking power
  300. 38:19 and it unfolded in the last 20 years all over the world putin is a man of the
  301. 38:25 masses oban is a man of the masses nikola groeski in macedonia was a man of the masses bolsonaro in brazil duterte in the philippines
  302. 38:36 donald trump in the united states they’re all people of the masses they’re
  303. 38:43 all representatives of the muscles in the centers of power in the swamp in the swamp of the elites
  304. 38:52 and of course the elites had no intention to take this lying down and they are going
  305. 38:59 to react and we’re going to discuss this reaction a bit later but before we do this
  306. 39:06 we need to understand something about the repertory of the elites how do the elites
  307. 39:12 co-opt the middle class how do they subjugate the masses what are the secret tools signaling and
  308. 39:20 messaging that they deploy when they succeed to regain and retake power because the elites have been have been challenged thousands of times throughout history and they never ever failed numerous movements rooted in the middle
  309. 39:38 class for example in 1848 rooted in in the in the masses for example in the 1930s there have been numerous challenges to the elites to the power structures
  310. 39:50 numerous challenges and the elites saw them off they elude the elites
  311. 39:56 succeeded to suppress eliminate destroy and reverse
  312. 40:02 every challenge ever thrown at them the elites are very creative sometimes
  313. 40:08 they come up with with sham sham concessions such as democracy
  314. 40:14 sometimes they come with a unif unifying narrative such as nationalism maybe i’m elite maybe ramas but we belong to the same nation sometimes they have many ways and the elites are not
  315. 40:26 a conspiracy the elites are not a coordinated bunch they don’t pick up the phone every morning and coordinate actions the elites have common interests and that’s enough common interests
  316. 40:38 dictate common causes of action common behaviors common cognitions common emotions common
  317. 40:45 derision of the masses common contempt common hatred common everything when you have common interests with someone you don’t need to talk to them you’re both likely to act the same way
  318. 40:57 and so the elites are are a diffuse mass they’re like more
  319. 41:04 like a cloud you know they’re more like a cloud and they’re diffuse mass that permeates
  320. 41:11 every crevice and nook and cranny of society and they have common interests above all
  321. 41:17 the interest of stability and self-preservation so that they can increase enhance their wealth and transfer it to the next generation that’s the main interest of the elite
  322. 41:28 the selfish gene and so the elites use a variety of psychological manipulation techniques on the masses via the middle class
  323. 41:39 the mediators the intermediaries other middle class for example middle class intellectuals
  324. 41:46 middle class intellectuals write all the influential books and come up
  325. 41:52 with all the amazing captivating ideologies that the masses adhere to unthinkingly
  326. 42:00 but the middle class is operating on behalf of the elites whatever they say whatever they do whatever they write
  327. 42:06 is intended to preserve the system very few intellectuals are real subversives they are not even when they sound as though they are rebellious and subversive they are not they are hyper
  328. 42:18 conservative the middle class is much more conservative than the elites and all philosophical systems were
  329. 42:25 invented by the elites in the middle class to subjugate the masses all religions have the same purpose exactly to keep the masses in check so religions
  330. 42:36 and philosophical systems they can be divided into three options there are three ways of going about it
  331. 42:43 one the psychotic school magical thinking and misperceiving internal objects as
  332. 42:50 external and the most famous example is of course god god is an internal object it’s a confabulation it’s a concoction it’s a piece of fiction and yet the elites with the middle class
  333. 43:02 had succeeded to convince the masses that god is an external object it’s really out there and what does god
  334. 43:09 tell the masses support the elites support the current the existing order don’t rebel be good be good boys be good citizens pay your taxes work
  335. 43:20 hard for the elites because if you work hard someone in the elite is getting richer
  336. 43:28 religions are instruments of the elite to control the masses via magical thinking opium
  337. 43:36 the second school is the narcissistic school entitlement rights obligations
  338. 43:42 hubris the narcissistic school mistakes external objects and symbols
  339. 43:48 for internal ones so for example the rule of law it’s like the law is something outside
  340. 43:55 you and the law has its own existence then the law must prevail the law must rule but if you have a
  341. 44:02 close look at the law the law is a manipulative tool of the elites to take whatever you have enrich themselves and then preserve the wealth against your rage and transfer it to the next generations to their next generations the law
  342. 44:22 is confiscatory the law is exclusionary the rule of law is a code word for stagnation so the narcissistic school lets you believe that there is something outside you which is bigger than you
  343. 44:39 more important than you and demands your sacrifice i mentioned the law there’s also the nation the nation is an invention of the elites of course so it gives you the sense that
  344. 44:52 you and you belong that you accepted that you’re part of the club that you’re a member of a club you have you feel entitled different you have rights you have obligations and it caters to your grandiosity you no longer feel a member of the great
  345. 45:08 unwashed elite masses you feel an otto almost member of the elite because you
  346. 45:16 both belong to the same nation and both of you are subject to the same laws i have a surprise for you laws are for
  347. 45:23 masses never for the elites no member of the elite is subject to any law and when i say any law i mean any law the last solution of the elites on how
  348. 45:34 to subjugate and co-opt the masses is the schizoid school
  349. 45:40 withdrawing from the world and shunning reality altogether and this is a solution this is the
  350. 45:47 preferred solution of the elites they give you mass media they give you soap operas they give you reality tv they give you the internet they give you all these things because they want to
  351. 45:58 push you away from reality they want to get you addicted they want to condition you
  352. 46:04 they want you to forget about reality because reality is the elites the reality is 99 of the world is owned
  353. 46:11 by the elites when i say elite i mean a few thousand people and so they don’t want you to pay
  354. 46:19 attention to this they want your eyeballs they don’t want you to have intimacy because any minute you have intimacy is a minute lost to zuckerberg and facebook and zuckerberg’s pocket they don’t want
  355. 46:33 you to say anything subversive or controversial or politically incorrect or
  356. 46:39 and if you do they cut you off even if you are the president of the united states they want you to live in a confabulated
  357. 46:47 fabricated nonsensical counterfactual fallacious fantasy world
  358. 46:54 they want you to inhabit a dreamscape they even give you opioids to ascertain that this happens
  359. 47:03 this is the schizoid solution in any given period of history one of these schools is on the ascendant
  360. 47:10 and the other two are on the defensive the elites experiment with one of these
  361. 47:17 three solutions the psychotic solution the narcissistic solution in the schizoid
  362. 47:24 solution and some sometimes some periods in history the psychotic solution is the dominant
  363. 47:30 solution so people believe in gods and religions and angels and i don’t know what else some other periods of history the
  364. 47:36 narcissistic solution is on the ascendant and so people believe that they can
  365. 47:42 become rich and powerful and and and so on and so forth because they are sold on an american dream or
  366. 47:48 some kind of dream and at other periods of history the schizoid solution is dominant and the other two are a bit recessive in our post-modern world the two
  367. 48:00 dominant solutions are alternately narcissism and schizoid
  368. 48:06 what happened with the pandemic the pandemic didn’t create a single trend the pandemic didn’t didn’t render anything different or new what
  369. 48:17 the pandemic did was shine a bright light on reality it forced us to confront
  370. 48:24 reality first of all there was a massive transfer of wealth from poor people to rich people
  371. 48:31 billionaires in the pandemic had increased their wealth in a single year by 59
  372. 48:38 why did they take this money from you of course they took this money from you poor
  373. 48:44 people had transferred their wealth to the richest people on earth that’s the first effect of the pandemic second effect all the sham and fake
  374. 48:57 narratives that the elites were selling you free speech human rights civil rights
  375. 49:03 democracy and other they are now taking away from you
  376. 49:09 because it doesn’t serve them right right now so you realize that these were not natural rights this was not something god given
  377. 49:22 free speech free association free demonstrations and protests free
  378. 49:28 anything is the gift of the elites is given to you by the elites
  379. 49:34 and can be taken away from you at any minute none of it is yours not your property
  380. 49:41 not your freedom not your speech nothing it all belongs to the elites
  381. 49:48 they deluded you into thinking that you own these things because there is a law
  382. 49:54 because there is a nation because there’s a community because it’s common destiny they lie to
  383. 50:01 you because there’s democracy and you have influence over the proceedings and you have power they
  384. 50:08 lied to you your brain did and they took advantage of this and now in the pandemic you see a suppression of free speech and the elimination outright of the vast
  385. 50:20 majority of human and civil rights and cast into sharp relief
  386. 50:27 like under a huge projector you see who is in charge and who is in charge are
  387. 50:36 technologies owners of technology companies finance and
  388. 50:44 to some extent but it’s extremely limited um other types of businesses so business
  389. 50:53 the corporate world especially multinationals international banks international technology companies they’re in charge
  390. 51:00 they’re the elite this is the nexus these are the elites most of them are billionaires and so
  391. 51:06 these are the elites they rule you and control you had it been different 200 years ago of course not international bankers have ruled the
  392. 51:13 world during napoleon’s time it’s the same elites the same elites
  393. 51:19 ruled babylon the same the people with money the people with technology they ruled the
  394. 51:25 world always 10 000 years ago the people who invented the agricultural revolution the people who came up who came up with
  395. 51:31 the industrial revolution mining mine owners factory owners
  396. 51:37 these are the elites these have always been the elites they shape-shifted to deceive you they
  397. 51:43 pretended to introduce members of the middle class into the exclusive elite club this was
  398. 51:49 intended to deceive you give you false hope that one day maybe you can belong
  399. 51:55 it’s a deception no intellectual is member of these elites
  400. 52:01 they co-opt they kind of collaborate with certain intellectuals they adopt certain intellectuals they elevate
  401. 52:07 certain intellectuals to make these intellectuals feel that you know they have real power somehow to move the muscles who cares about the muscles the muscles can move left and can move right
  402. 52:18 they’re useless they’re useless because ultimately the elite is there even when the masses
  403. 52:24 did take over for example in communism in nazism nazism was a corporate i mean was
  404. 52:31 immediately compromised by corporate industrial interests
  405. 52:37 so so was fascism and communism communism fell prey to the managerial
  406. 52:43 class who is the managerial class people with money people with technological skills
  407. 52:51 so the pandemic revealed to us how powerless we are and how powerless we’ve always been and
  408. 52:59 the pandemic of course has geopolitical implications as well it has accelerated the decline of the
  409. 53:06 united states and restored the historically dominant eurasian landmass
  410. 53:13 throughout human history the dominant power was china contiguous china not the united states
  411. 53:21 the united states and the west it’s an aberration aberration established by refugees
  412. 53:27 criminals privateers pirates and so on
  413. 53:33 the entire so-called western civilization is founded on crime it’s founded on persecution is founded
  414. 53:41 by outcasts and outliers it had not not show no chance in the world to survive
  415. 53:47 500 years which is the length of western civilization is nothing in historical terms it’s a bleach it’s a
  416. 53:53 glitch it’s a it’s a blip it’s not nothing and it’s ending western civilization is ending it was an experiment by outliers and outcasts and
  417. 54:06 the elites are going to eliminate it it took them 500 years which is shocking in itself but they’re going to eliminate western civilization the old powers the
  418. 54:17 historical powers which is china and its extension russia the eurasian table is rising up again as it had done for thousands of years long before there was any concept of the
  419. 54:28 west when europe was a big swamp russia today is providing weapons not only to
  420. 54:35 serbia but to nato allies like turkey russia had cast itself as an important diplomatic force
  421. 54:41 in the middle east not only in syria but even in countries like israel russia is emerging as technological and
  422. 54:47 scientific power both for good vaccines and for bad hacking
  423. 54:54 but russia is a minor player russia is china’s extension he just doesn’t know it yet china
  424. 55:01 is now pivoting from a strictly economic superpower to a military superpower that’s where
  425. 55:08 the game begins that’s where the game is afoot as my friend charlo holmes would have said russia is purchasing critical infrastructure the belt the road silk road critical infrastructure
  426. 55:20 everywhere greece africa latin america you name it chinese are there
  427. 55:26 lending buying selling establishing building it’s a chinese world china’s soft power
  428. 55:34 has surpassed the united states in terms of lending to sovereigns online social media payments and retail
  429. 55:41 platforms and propaganda china’s gdp is nearly the same as the united states
  430. 55:48 and the entire european union block what can small countries do
  431. 55:56 small countries cannot afford to surf the wrong geopolitical wave small countries must strike a neutral
  432. 56:03 stance between east and west even if it means that small countries have to postpone certain supranational aspirations like joining the european union
  433. 56:15 small countries should adopt the swiss model and welcome everyone and i think the united kingdom was a
  434. 56:21 harbinger and a pioneer of this approach with brexit small countries should
  435. 56:27 redirect themselves and embrace industries which do not render them dependent on either superpower
  436. 56:33 services green agriculture medical tourism offshore banking coding back office operations you name it this is small countries what can you do as a member of the mass
  437. 56:45 opt out do not collaborate do not be a slave just walk away
  438. 56:54 nothingness adopt nothingness not it’s wrong to advise you
  439. 57:01 to go back to a totally imaginary past where men were men and women were women
  440. 57:08 and families were families and nations were nations there was never ever such a past it was all
  441. 57:14 an illusionary facade ocuspokus perpetrated by the elites they had deceived you
  442. 57:23 it was a magician’s sleight of hand it was never real it was a decoy jordan peterson’s vision
  443. 57:30 is a decoy the guy is delusional this was never
  444. 57:36 such a thing the world the kind of world they described in this sense he’s indistinguishable from donald trump make america great
  445. 57:43 again i don’t know when america was great it was like the um
  446. 57:50 illusion or hallucination of of a britain that had never existed in the 19th century
  447. 57:56 these are these are psychedelic experiments by the elites on your mind
  448. 58:03 to defeat the elites the masses must walk away not walk away from jobs you need to live
  449. 58:11 you need to eat you need to drink you need to raise a family i’m not i’m not advocating uh becoming a
  450. 58:17 lone wolf in a forest walk away from the dream denounce and renounce the fantasy stop participating in the race minimize
  451. 58:29 consumption damage them fight them back with their own weapons democracy
  452. 58:38 is a sham don’t participate consumerism is an addiction don’t
  453. 58:46 consume the rat race is designed designed to keep you too busy to think
  454. 58:54 don’t quit the rat race focus on you
  455. 59:02 they want you to focus outside that’s why they had created these technological platforms social media and so on so that you are so much outside your mind that you are not
  456. 59:14 aware they reduce your awareness they they hypnotize you they sedate you
  457. 59:21 they entrain you these are pernicious sick brainwashing tactics do not willingly
  458. 59:28 succumb don’t go into the mental asylum of the elites willingly and extend your hands for the
  459. 59:36 straight jacket fight back fight back by not fighting fight back civil disobedience passive resistance
  460. 59:48 opt out tune out choose nothingness watch my new channel
  461. 59:55 subscribe to my new channel on nothingness where i elaborate on these topics i hope i introduce some order and
  462. 60:02 meaning and structure into the chaos that is today’s world you have any questions post them in the
  463. 60:09 comment section i’ll do my best to respond or even create a new video thank you for listening
Facebook
X
LinkedIn
WhatsApp

https://vakninsummaries.com/ (Full summaries of Sam Vaknin’s videos)

http://www.narcissistic-abuse.com/mediakit.html (My work in psychology: Media Kit and Press Room)

Bonus Consultations with Sam Vaknin or Lidija Rangelovska (or both) http://www.narcissistic-abuse.com/ctcounsel.html

http://www.youtube.com/samvaknin (Narcissists, Psychopaths, Abuse)

http://www.youtube.com/vakninmusings (World in Conflict and Transition)

http://www.narcissistic-abuse.com (Malignant Self-love: Narcissism Revisited)

http://www.narcissistic-abuse.com/cv.html (Biography and Resume)

Summary

The speaker discussed the historical dominance of elites over politics and society, how the middle class was co-opted to control the masses, and the subsequent rise of mass movements challenging elite power. They highlighted the role of technology, such as the printing press and social media, in redistributing power to the masses, leading to populist movements and democratic participation, albeit within a system still largely controlled by elites. The pandemic further exposed systemic inequalities and elite control, prompting a call for individuals to resist manipulation and opt out of the societal rat race to reclaim personal agency. Watch This to Make Sense of the World

Tags

If you enjoyed this article, you might like the following:

Violent Innocence of Narcissist’s Victimhood (Passive-aggression)

In this video, Sam Vaknin discussed the concept of “violent innocence,” a psychological defense mechanism common in narcissists, where individuals cause harm while denying responsibility and insisting on their moral superiority. He explained how covert narcissists exhibit passive aggression through behaviors like gaslighting, procrastination, and performative compliance or obnoxiousness, all

Read More »

Avoid Toxic Love of Toxic People

In this video, Sam Vaknin explored the concept of toxic and conditional love, emphasizing how unhealthy early experiences with love lead individuals to misinterpret and rely on corrupted forms of affection characterized by performance, coercion, and manipulation. He explained the detrimental effects such as codependency, borderline behaviors, triangulation, and infidelity,

Read More »

Predatory Women (Compilation 2 of 2)

The video provided an in-depth analysis of female psychopaths, distinguishing them from male psychopaths by their impulsivity, emotional dysregulation, and relational abuse within a chaotic, manipulative “crazymaking space” aimed at gaining power. It also explored borderline personality disorder, particularly focusing on splitting, self-destructive behaviors, and substance abuse as coping mechanisms

Read More »

Is Covert Narcissism Rising Among Young?

The video discussed two major studies on narcissism trends among young people, highlighting the controversy and replication crisis in psychology, particularly concerning rising narcissism claims from a 2008 study compared to a 2025 global meta-analysis showing no increase or even a decline in overt narcissism. It emphasized that current research

Read More »

Narcissist’s Fantasy Not About YOU, Psychopath’s Is (Collateral Victimhood)

In this video, San Vaknin clarified the distinction between narcissistic and psychopathic fantasies, emphasizing that narcissistic fantasies revolve around the narcissist’s grandiose self-concept and needs, while psychopathic fantasies focus on fulfilling the victim’s desires. He explained that narcissists are impaired in reality testing due to their reliance on delusional fantasies

Read More »

Narcissism: 3 Frenchmen Ask, Prof. Answers (with Antoine Peytavin and Friends)

In this video, Professor Sam Vaknin discussed narcissism, its nature as a genetic trait, cultural phenomenon, and personality disorder, emphasizing its profound psychological and societal impacts. He explained the distinctions between overt and covert narcissism, the role of narcissistic supply, and the complexities of diagnosing and treating narcissistic personality disorder.

Read More »

Why I am Hopelessly Depressed (Self-efficacy)

The speaker reflects on their diminished self-efficacy, attributing it not only to personal failures but significantly to drastic societal and cultural changes that undermine rationality, intelligence, and traditional values rooted in the Enlightenment. They highlight the rise of anti-intellectualism, nihilism, and a decline in critical thinking as contributing factors leading

Read More »

Halloween: Paranormal Treat or Narcissist’s Trick? (The Nerve with Maureen Callahan)

In this discussion, Sam Vaknin explores the psychological and philosophical dimensions of paranormal experiences, emphasizing their real impact on human perception despite a lack of scientific validation. He critiques scientism and highlights the role of emotional arousal, misattribution, and early developmental experiences in shaping supernatural beliefs, while acknowledging rare unexplained

Read More »

Narcissist’s Impostor Syndrome and Hypervigilance

The speaker discussed the narcissist’s tendency to misinterpret compliments as insults due to their underlying imposter syndrome, which causes chronic self-doubt and hypervigilance. The conversation distinguished between imposter syndrome, characterized by internalized feelings of fraudulence in narcissists, and imposter phenomenon, where competent individuals feel undeserving despite their achievements. The speaker

Read More »

Narcissism: Jung’s Mother Archetype Absent

In this video, the speaker discussed Carl Gustav Jung’s concept of the mother archetype, emphasizing its complexity beyond the typical nurturing and loving image, highlighting its role in self-love and individuation. The speaker explained how the archetype represents internal self-nurturing qualities, contrasting this with pathological narcissism, where individuals fail to

Read More »